Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to Things-to-do In Savannah Blog

Where to Get Thanksgiving Pie in Savannah, GA

Three pies, yams, marshmallows, and orange drinks on a peach background.

When November arrives in Savannah, so does one of the most anticipated seasonal menus in town. Pie Society’s Autumn Edition Seasonal Pie Drop has award-winning turkey pie, pumpkin, apple, and pecan pies, and handheld pasties made for exploring. If you’re spending the holidays in the Hostess City or filling your own Thanksgiving table, here’s where to get the best Thanksgiving pie in Savannah.

Why Pie Society Is Savannah’s Holiday Pie Destination

Pie Society opened in Pooler in 2013. The family behind it brought recipes from their hometown in Staffordshire, England, and they’ve since been named the Best Pie Shop in Georgia by 24/7 Wall St. Their pies are amazing all year, but the holidays are when Pie Society really shines.

Visiting Savannah for Thanksgiving or the Holidays?

What to Try While You’re in Town

If you’re coming to Savannah in November or December, you’ll want to taste the season while you’re here. Make The Little Crown by Pie Society in City Market one of your first stops.

  • Award-Winning Turkey, Stuffing & Cranberry Pie: This is the best Thanksgiving pie in Savannah, and people go crazy for it. It’s a flaky, savory meat pie with a sweet and tangy touch of cranberry, so it’s like a full Thanksgiving plate in a personal-sized pie. It’s got tender, juicy turkey breast in a brown turkey gravy with layers of sage stuffing and jellied cranberry.
  • Ham, Stuffing & Apple Pasty : Pasties are handheld pies, so you can eat this one as you walk through the Historic District’s squares, under the oaks, past homes dressed up for the holidays.
  • Mini dessert pies: Try a few. The Pumpkin, Pecan, Toffee Apple Crumble, and Dubai Chocolate pies all come in mini sizes.
  • Shortbread: Pumpkin Spice Caramel or Cranberry Orange makes an easy treat to take back to your hotel.

If you’re staying in a vacation rental or hotel for the holiday, you can still have a proper Thanksgiving or holiday meal without cooking. Pre-order the Pie Night bundle. It comes with a large meat pie, a side, and a dessert pie, and it feeds 2 to 3 people. Just place your order at least 24 hours ahead.

Savannah Locals: Thanksgiving Pies for Your Table

The Main Event

The large Award-Winning Turkey, Stuffing & Cranberry Pie gives your crowd every traditional Thanksgiving flavor without hours in the kitchen.

Best Pumpkin Pie, Apple Pie, and Pecan Pie in Savannah, GA

Here are a few traditional pies and some with a twist for a fun, delicious alternative.

  • Best pumpkin pie in Savannah, GA: You can get a classic Pumpkin pie or try their Pumpkin Biscoff Pie for a twist.
  • Best apple pie in Savannah, GA: The Toffee Apple Crumble is a British spin on a holiday favorite.
  • Best pecan pie in Savannah, GA: You can choose the traditional Pecan Pie or turn things up a bit with a more decadent Chocolate Pecan Pie for the chocolate lovers.

Pie Society Locations

The Little Crown by Pie Society (Downtown Savannah)

19 Jefferson St, Savannah, GA 31401 (City Market)
If you’re visiting, this is the spot. It’s a tiny British pub and pie house in the Historic District, a short walk from River Street, Broughton Street, and the downtown squares. Stop in for a pie and a British-themed cocktail, or grab a pasty to go.

Crown & Anchor Pub with Pie Society (Pooler)

US Highway 80 E, Pooler, GA
If you live west of downtown, or you’re flying in and out of Savannah/Hilton Head International Airport, the Pooler location near I-95 makes holiday pickup easy.

View the full menu here…

Pie Society seasonal menu with prices, pie types, meal deals, and preorder options.

Pie Society released their 2026 Autumn Edition Menu on November 1st. The menu is subject to change based on daily sales and availability. Please contact Pie Society directly to place an order. 

 

Looking for more Thanksgiving menus in Savannah? Check out our recent blog post, Restaurants Open on Thanksgiving in Savannah, GA (2026).